Would You Bet the Brand on an Answer No Human Ever Gave?
Imagine spending $250,000 on a campaign built around the promise “Set up in minutes.”
Your team tested three headlines. This one won. Then someone asks the question that should have come up before you bought the ads. How many of the people who picked that headline have ever set up your product? If the audience was synthetic, the answer is zero.
Credit for the question in our headline goes to Jodie Shaw of Kadence International. In her article for Quirk’s, Shaw suggests a test I’d run before signing a media plan.
Write down which campaign the AI recommends. Run the study independently with real buyers, and do an expression analysis of how they give their answers. Then see whether you’d spend the money the same way.
Take that setup promise. A model can give you sensible reasons why a busy buyer values speed. Now ask someone who installed your software last Tuesday what happened.
Maybe setup really did take eight minutes. Getting permission from IT took three weeks. Your headline makes an accurate promise about the part of the job your customer barely remembers.
The real answer from a human gives marketing a different idea to test. Show buyers what their IT team needs to approve the purchase. Ask the next few customers who signed off what questions came back, and which document would have saved them a week.
That’s why we built Emma, the AI interviewer at ReadingMinds. Send customers a link. Emma asks questions by voice and can follow up on what each person says. When a theme shows up in your report, you can trace it back to their exact words and use that in your marketing copy.
Synthetic respondents can be very useful because they allow you to test your messaging and/or surveys, but before you or your agent approve your next campaign, get actual evidence from the people you expect to buy. Give them room to surprise you.
About the author

Stu Sjouwerman
CEO and Co-Founder, ReadingMinds.AI
Stu founded KnowBe4 in 2010 and grew it into the world's largest security-awareness training platform before taking it public on the NASDAQ in 2021 and its subsequent acquisition by Vista Equity Partners in 2023. He co-founded ReadingMinds with Marcio Castilho and Alin Irimie, the same leadership team that built KnowBe4. Author of the USA Today bestseller Agent-Powered Growth and a regular contributor to Forbes Tech Council and Greenbook on AI, agentic marketing, and customer intelligence.
Know what your customers feel. Not just what they say.
ReadingMinds conducts AI voice interviews that classify emotion type and intensity. Try a 3-minute Live Test Drive with Emma.
Start 3‑Minute Live Test Drive